Elena vs. Caroline: Who Was the True Queen of The Vampire Diaries?

In a show filled with vampires, witches, and werewolves, The Vampire Diaries had no shortage of strong female characters. But when it comes to the title of “Queen of TVD,” two names dominate the conversation: Elena Gilbert and Caroline Forbes.

Elena was the heart of the show—the central character whose love life, friendships, and tragedies drove the storyline. Meanwhile, Caroline started as a secondary character but evolved into one of the most powerful and independent women in the series. So, the question remains: Who was the true queen of The Vampire Diaries?

—

The Case for Elena: The Show’s Emotional Core

From the very first episode, The Vampire Diaries was built around Elena Gilbert. Her love triangle with the Salvatore brothers defined the show’s most intense moments. She wasn’t just the girl caught between two vampires; she was the character who constantly faced heartbreak, loss, and supernatural chaos, yet always found a way to survive.

Why Elena deserves the crown:

She was the show’s main character, and most storylines revolved around her.

Her love story with Stefan and Damon became one of TV’s most iconic romances.

She suffered immense losses (her parents, Jenna, Jeremy, etc.) and still carried on.

As a vampire, she struggled with her humanity but ultimately found her way back.

Without Elena, there would be no TVD—she was the glue that held everything together.

However, many fans argue that Elena was often too much of a damsel in distress, relying on the Salvatore brothers to save her. Some also felt her character lost depth after becoming a vampire and that she wasn’t as independent as other women in the show.

—

The Case for Caroline: The Ultimate Glow-Up

Caroline Forbes started as the stereotypical high school mean girl, but over the seasons, she transformed into one of the most powerful and well-developed characters in the series. Unlike Elena, who struggled with vampirism, Caroline thrived as a vampire. She embraced her strength, became a leader, and was one of the few characters who didn’t let love define her entire existence.

Why Caroline deserves the crown:

Her character growth was unmatched—from insecure and shallow to strong and independent.

She was one of the best vampires in the series, maintaining control over her urges.

Her friendships (especially with Stefan and Bonnie) were some of the most genuine in the show.

She became a leader in Mystic Falls, proving she didn’t need a man to define her worth.

Even in The Originals and Legacies, her influence remained strong.

Some argue that Caroline was too perfect—she rarely made mistakes, and her storylines often lacked real stakes compared to Elena’s constant suffering. Others felt she was sometimes overly judgmental, especially in earlier seasons.

—

Final Verdict: Who Wore the Crown?

The answer depends on what makes a true queen. If it’s about being the heart of the story, then Elena takes the title—she was the show’s driving force. But if it’s about growth, strength, and leadership, Caroline undeniably deserves the crown.

One thing’s for sure: both women left their mark on The Vampire Diaries universe. So, what do you think? Was Elena the true queen, or did Caroline steal the throne? Let the debate begin!